Now live Black Friday✓ HSA/FSA eligible² | 30-day money-backShop now
Now live Black Friday Two worlds, one sale. Wellness or Play, pick yours.✓ HSA/FSA eligible² | 30-day money-back

Your running playlist: what 139 studies found

Written byAnastasia DeripaskaPublished Reading7 min
A runner in a light jacket mid-stride on a riverside path at sunrise, autumn trees along the water

In one treadmill study, a plain metronome kept runners going about as long as motivating music did. Silence came last.

So what is the music doing, whether you run, walk or ride? A review of 139 studies and two closer experiments give a practical answer, and it starts with your feet. With big city marathons on the fall calendar, the timing is right to look at music for running.

What 139 studies add up to

In 2020, sport psychologists Peter Terry, Costas Karageorghis and colleagues pulled together the research on music in exercise and sport. Their meta-analysis in Psychological Bulletin combined 139 studies with 3,599 participants in total.

Here is what music was linked with, compared to the same activity without it. The numbers are the review's effect sizes (Hedges' g), where about 0.2 counts as small and about 0.5 as moderate:

  • Mood during exercise: a moderate lift in how good the activity felt (0.48). This was the strongest effect in the review.
  • Performance: a small improvement (0.31).
  • Perceived exertion: a small drop in how hard the effort felt (0.22).
  • Oxygen use: a very small drop (0.15).
  • Heart rate: no clear difference.

In plain terms, small means real but modest. Music did not turn anyone into a different athlete. It nudged the experience, and the nudge was biggest in how the workout felt.

Two details stand out. The performance effect was larger in everyday exercise than in competitive sport. And fast music helped performance more than slow or medium tempo music.

Close-up of plain running shoes striking a damp path scattered with autumn leaves

Why a beat changes the way you move

People tend to fall into step with a beat, often without noticing. Musicians call it entrainment. If the tempo of a song is close to your stride, your feet will drift toward it.

A 2013 study in PLOS ONE from VU University Amsterdam tested this on 19 recreational runners aged 19 to 27. Each ran on a treadmill until exhaustion three times, on separate days: once in silence, once to a metronome matched to their own cadence, and once to motivational music with the same beat.

With no sound, they lasted about 10 minutes on average. With either the metronome or the music, they ran about two minutes longer. The music did not beat the plain metronome on time. Runners rated the effort slightly lower with the music, a small difference. A steadier stride showed up clearly only with the metronome, not with the music. The authors suggested two forces at work: motivation from music, and a steadier stride from a clear beat.

Tempo: find your number

So which songs work best? The review found that faster music, above 120 beats per minute, went with bigger performance effects. A useful starting point for picking songs is your own cadence: the number of steps you take in a minute.

  • Count it. Run at an easy pace for 30 seconds and count every time your right foot lands. Multiply by four to get your steps per minute.
  • Match it. Look for songs whose beats per minute are close to that number. Many music apps list the tempo of a track, and some build running playlists by tempo.
  • Or use half time. A song at half your cadence works too: one foot lands on each beat, the other halfway between.

Say you count 42 landings in 30 seconds. That is 168 steps per minute, so songs near 168 beats per minute, or near 84 in half time, are a good place to start.

The review did not test matching songs to a runner's own cadence, so take that as a practical idea, not a finding.

Why your favorite song matters

Tempo is not the whole story. The same review found the biggest effect was on mood, and tempo did not change that mood effect. That part is personal. The track that lifts one runner leaves another cold.

A 2009 study in the Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology put this to the test. Thirty young adults walked briskly on a treadmill until they had to stop, three times. Once with music they found motivating, once with neutral music at the same tempo, and once in silence. Both kinds of music kept them going longer than silence did, and the motivating music did more than the neutral one. How hard the walk felt did not change much.

Karageorghis and colleagues even built a short questionnaire, the Brunel Music Rating Inventory, so exercisers and instructors can rate how motivating a track feels before they use it. The point is that a track's pull depends on the listener. A playlist built from songs you already love may suit you better than a chart of top running anthems.

What the evidence cannot tell you

The effects in the big review are averages across very different studies: cycling, running, strength work and sport, in labs and in the field. The review's authors rated every included study as low to moderate in quality, and since listeners always know when music is playing, no study could be double-blind. Studies of clinical or special groups were left out, so the findings describe general exercisers only. Music is not a training plan, and it will not replace the miles.

There is also a good case for some runs without it. Many runners like to learn the feel of their own pace. On roads and shared paths, your ears are part of how you stay aware of traffic, bikes and other people, so keep one ear open or use open style earbuds. The WHO suggests keeping a device at no more than 60 percent of its maximum volume, and notes that safe listening time gets shorter as the level rises: up to 40 hours a week at 80 decibels, but only 4 hours at 90.

A small group of runners seen from behind on a tree-lined park path in autumn haze

Three playlists worth building

These are our suggestions, not study findings. Whatever the day, open with slower songs for the warm up and build toward your pace. Then match the rest to the run:

  • Easy days: songs at or a little below your cadence, with a relaxed feel. The goal is to settle, not to chase.
  • Tempo days: songs right at your cadence or a touch above, with a strong, clear beat you can lock onto.
  • Long runs: a mix, with your most motivating tracks saved for the last third, when the miles start to feel heavy.

Bass carries the beat

Low notes carry the rhythm in most songs, and a strong beat is one you can feel as well as hear. Our earlier story looked at why bass makes you move. And if you track your runs with a watch, our story on how heart rate variability is calculated explains one of the numbers on your wrist.

Your next run, as an experiment

The research says music can make the effort feel better, and sometimes a little lighter. That is a modest claim, but it is one you can test for free. On your next run, try one thing: count your steps, then pick a song that matches them. Notice whether your feet find the beat before you do. Then run the same route in silence next week, and compare how each run felt.

This article is for general information only and is not medical advice.

Sources

  1. Terry PC, Karageorghis CI, Curran ML, Martin OV, Parsons-Smith RL. Effects of music in exercise and sport: a meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin, 2020.
  2. Bood RJ, Nijssen M, van der Kamp J, Roerdink M. The power of auditory-motor synchronization in sports: enhancing running performance by coupling cadence with the right beats. PLOS ONE, 2013.
  3. World Health Organization. Deafness and hearing loss: safe listening (questions and answers).
  4. Karageorghis CI, Mouzourides DA, Priest DL, et al. Psychophysical and ergogenic effects of synchronous music during treadmill walking. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2009.
  5. Karageorghis CI, Priest DL, Terry PC, Chatzisarantis NL, Lane AM. Redesign and initial validation of an instrument to assess the motivational qualities of music in exercise: the Brunel Music Rating Inventory-2. Journal of Sports Sciences, 2006.